I have never found a mascara I liked more than Maybeline’s basic pink & green one. I tried this out so when I curled my lashes they stayed. This mascara is everything I could ask for and more. It is very very waterproof. Even after rubbing with water my lashes have barely even lost any curl. That said, I have not figured out what product to use to remove it. I have tried a makeup removing sponge, 2 cleansers, miceller water. Wearing the mascara in these photos plus sheglam liquid contour, and lip stain